Wednesday, September 28, 2011
Week 9 (Rachel)
Wednesday, September 21, 2011
Week 8 (Rachel)
Monday, September 19, 2011
week eight [rhian]
Film Adaptations of P. K. D.:
- Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep (novel) - Blade Runner
- We Can Remember it for You Wholesale (short story) - Total Recall (1990 + 2012)
- Confessions of a Crap Artist (novel) - Barjo
- Second Variety (short story) - Screamers
- The Minority Report (short story) - Minority Report
- Imposters (short story) - Imposters (film) and Out of This World (television)
- Paycheck (short story) - Paycheck
- A Scanner Darkly (novel) - A Scanner Darkly
- The Golden Man (short story) - Next
- Adjustment Team (short story) - The Adjustment Bureau
- Plus more coming out next year
It is commonly said that 'Blade Runner' is the most successful of P. K. D's adaptations. The fact that there have been multitudes of releases shows that there is always interest in this movie. Despite the fact that when it first came out, Blade Runner wasn't considered very popular, it's popularity has grown over the years and is now considered a cult classic by almost all film buffs. Though the differences between the film and novel are vast, they both bring something to the table and in the film, you can see Dick's imprint all over it (yes, every version).
Another popular adaptation that has been seen as successful is 'Minority Report'. The reason this has been seen as so successful is because a popular actor at the time, Tom Cruise, was the main character, and so a very popular movie. Also, as Steven Spielberg was the director, it was also popular for that. It compares to the original novel with having the basics of the story - characters, primary motives, climactic turnaround point, but a lot of the ulterior motives and details have been adapted to suit the film.
The third most successful film would be 'A Scanner Darkly'. It is very original as it used a rather rare form of presentation called rotoscopy: live action with animation done on top to give it an unrealistic looking feature. Keanu Reeves and Winona Ryder were the main actors in it. This is possibly one of the most relatable adaptation as most of the scenes are straight out of the book and put onto the screen. Only a few scenes were cut out and most of them are very well done.
Philip K. Dick has created some amazing works of writing and the adaptations are quite interesting. He is the go-to guy for science fiction movie enthusiasts and creators.
week seven [rhian]
Philip K. Dick used the I Ching as an aid while writing High Castle. He claimed that it was his directional guide, almost like a compass. At important crossroads within the novel, whilst writing, Dick would consult the I Ching as to where he should then go. Mountfort (2006) says "Dick regarded the I Ching itself as having in a sense written High Castle." It is also referenced in the book multiple times, even when consultations aren't made. It is used an a future telling device - an oracle.
There are ten separate consultations within the novel that Dick made. All of them include questions involving characters' decisions that need to be made. Involving how to treat another character or whether a character is worth pursuing. It is primarily based around the characters Frink and Tagomi and they are essentially the same questions, just different circumstances.
Frink and Tagomi, the protagonists, have their characteristics shown through the consultations Dick has used the I Ching for.
Frink has an ex-wife who is very arrogant and wants everything her own way. He also has business ventures that involve confronting his boss and going into another business (jewelry making). By using the I Ching in these situations, Frink is able to further understand what is to come.
Tagomi is a Japanese official. With this comes great responsibility and he deals with a lot of contacts, consulting the I Ching to understand them better. As he is a "highly ethical" person, by consulting the I Ching, he is able to make better decisions.
There are a few other characters that use the I Ching, but the protagonists of the story, Frink and Tagomi are the primary ones.
Despite the fact that in 1979, Dick regarded the I Ching as something that had led him astray in the worst possible way through the "final omen", High Castle received much praise and is still regarded today as great reading.
week six [rhian]
Princess Mononoke "undermines the myths of traditional Japanese identitiy" and gives a completely new one to go by. This involves creating completely new social constructions: gender, class and race. Miyazaki does this in a multitude of ways.
"Subversion and defamiliarisation" - Napier claims that this is quite possibly the most important strategy Miyazaki uses to reinvent the social constructions in traditional Japan. The defamiliarisation is of two important iconological motifs in Japan's history: that of females' traditional gender roles "supportive" and the like, as well as Japan's respect for nature. Mononoke challenges all of the Japanese conventions that have survived for years, running the state under the traditional ideals that have stemmed from its long history.
Miyazaki wrote "this is the story of the marginals of history." He aimed to bring the less known characters of tradition to the forefront and to shine a spotlight on them to tell their tale and give the ma sort of idol stature. These characters he familiarises with are non-conventional protagnoists such as "women, outcasts and non-Yamato (nonethnic Japanese)." With Mononoke, Hiyazaki was able to challenge the social constructions Japan stands by, by creating new heroes and heroines of the past. It makes for a less truthful account and a more interesting one.
"Princess Mononoke" does not aim to glorify the history or traditional ideals that is present throughout the scenes, but it creates a sense of uncertainty and problematic issues with the past that is usually a safe conventional bet in Japanese society. Miyazaki also influences the attitudes toward the traditional ideals through this movie, not as a serious, life changing opinion, but just in the movie.
Despite the problematic changing of traditional mythology in "Princess Mononoke" with the new gender roles, class structure and race inclusion, this is actually what draws the audience in because of it's originality and threshold breaking ideals. So instead of a negative view on the adaptations of conventions Miyazki has created, the new social constructions actually boosts Mononoke's popularity.
week five [rhian]
Shojo is a type of manga and anime. It is a genre. This genre covers storylines from drama to science fiction but they are all focused on one type of audience: that of young females, though older Japanese males are a large portion of the audience, primarily because it shows a different kind of theme that they are used to.
The term "shojo" can be translated to "female" in English but is always specifically a young female in Japanese culture. Cavallaro (2006) says "on the whole, the worlds depicted by shoujo stories are serenely dreamy and bathed in an atmosphere of magic and wonder..." and Prindle (1998) claims "the shoujo nestle in a shallow lacuna between adulthood and childhood, power and powerlessness, awareness and innocence as well as masculinity and femininity."
A great example of shojo in anime is in Miyazaki's creations. "Spirited Away" and "Princess Mononoke" both contain the ideal heroines by aesthetic means. They are both female and young. However, the storylines Miyazaki creates require these heroines to be more active than the generic ones. Although, in my opinion, Chihiro in "Spirited Away" may be more courageous than most shojo protagonists but she is the ultimate expression of a young female with her whining and complacency (in the beginning at least.)
Other examples of shojo anime and manga is "Sailor Moon", "Cardcaptor Sakura" and that hampster one that was super kawaii (cute).
(Week 6) What are the underlying thematics of Princess Mononoke? How does it ‘defamiliarise’ its historical setting, according to Napier (2005)?
Princess Mononoke takes on various themes that many aspects of Japanese History and folklore represent, including the status of people, different societies, outcasts and battles, both in a symbolic and literal form based on the Muromachi period (1336-1573). In the film, the main protagonists are those who do not necessarily appear on the stage of history as major characters, rather this is the story of history’s marginals. These marginals include women, outcasts and non-ethnic Japanese, who would rather go unnoticed. The film remoulds archetypes and icons and tells the story from their perspective. Some of the themes that the film follows are:
Ashitaka is an important character in this story because of the many trying circumstances he is placed under, beginning with him being cursed and prompting him to visit Iron Town whose people, he believes can rid him of the curse. Along the way he realizes how this community functions and he also encounters the character we come to know as Princess Mononoke. His final step in the story is his attempt to resolve the conflict between Eboshi (Head of Iron Town) and her people and the Animal Gods and Princess Mononoke, all while trying to uplift the curse bestowed upon him.
Ashitaka has heard tales of Princess Mononoke and is mysteriously drawn to her when he encounters her for the first time. Even though their first encounter is violent, later on the two tend stick up for each other. Eventually, they grow to build trust and understanding.
Lady Eboshi is responsible for a community of seemingly downtrodden people who have been turned away from their society. With nothing else to provide for her people, other than the resources that the forest has to offer, she depends, almost entirely on the forest. To Princess Mononoke and the Animal Gods, this is seen as a threat to their homes in the environment. Lady Eboshi is willing to take on her enemies, in order to look after those who cannot fight their own battles.
The story is set at a time when Japanese society was patriarchal. Yet in the film, at least two major (leading) characters, reveal the inconisation of women, Lady Eboshi who is the head of her community Iron Town and Princess Mononoke herself
Loss is another theme in Princess Mononoke. Both Mononoke and Ashitaka choose to carry on following their beliefs in what they are doing for the sake of their people who need them rather than come together.
The atmosphere of the story appears to be one of conflict at different levels. The people of Iron Town invade the forest to provide for themselves when they have nothing else to rely on and the people of the Forest including the Animal Gods and Princess Mononoke see this as a threat, in turn invading Iron Town and forcing them into battle. The story revolves around this conflict
The film is set in a fabled world which exists only in our imagination and the director has mixed together both reality (based on history) and the myths and legends of Japan to create this realm in the story.
The natural world in this story has been given a supernatural tone and is filled with its very own systems and laws, especially the inclusion of ‘Animal Gods’ or ‘Kami’ the ancient Gods of Japanese people who represent or are closely linked/related to Nature. It appears to defy most conventions of Japanese history and folklore with examples such as a town in the story governed not by a man but by a woman.
The story is set in the real world, presumably at the time of the Muromachi period, thus the historical setting is familiar in terms of the people, lifestyle and culture. However, it ‘defamiliarises’ its historical setting by creating “a mythical space deeply removed ........ symbolically and literally’ and by focussing on the ‘marginals’. Miyazaki has not focussed on the main characters of that era such as samurai, peasants and feudal lords. Instead the focus is on people who would have, around this time, gone unnoticed or are seen as outcasts again ‘defamiliarising’ the audience by using unconventional characters.
References
Napier, S (2005). Anime: from Akira to Howl’s Moving Castle. Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan
Saturday, September 10, 2011
Week 7 (Rachel)
Thursday, September 8, 2011
(Week 5) Looking at Napier and Cavallaro (2006), discuss how anime is culturally ‘located’ – in the East or West, or somewhere else?
Hampshire: Palgrave/ Macmillan
Week 8: How does Dick’s essay (1999; 1964) illuminate his use of Nazism as a motif in High Castle?
P.K. Dick, the author of “Nazism and The High Castle,” ponders on a review that was not done on the works itself, but specifically the idea behind the justification of the persecution that Nazis did during the Holocaust of WWII; and the inspirational years that lead the same victims of the Holocaust to forming a nationalistic entity, who then go on to apply these same methods that the Nazis used during their own persecution. This essay shows a complex set of intertwined ideas that exposes the readers mind to how Nazis justified their actions towards their victims during WWII, and how it is similar to the same actions that are done and justified by the Zionistic nationalists of Israel in the lands of the Palestinians.
Initially, Dicks essay starts by pondering on why the Nazis would do such acts to fulfill their superior ideological bigotry. But in reality, just as anyone would answer, the author is quoted by saying, “Phobia is phobia.” To keep it plain and simple, that’s the answer. But in this case, it gets more complicated since history is repeating itself, but in reverse this time. The Nazi persecution has given birth to an evil product that went on to repeat these same tactics, and the continuation of this same cycle in order to fulfill their own individual agenda.
For example, Dick clarifies the use of Nazism, as a motif, by pointing out that there were some elements such as the ‘Jewish Nationalist,’ that were “overlooked.” Also goes on to say, “...at the time of the rise of anti-Jewish ideology among non-Jewish-Germans, the Jewish-Germans were beginning, in great part, to think—as not Germans or even Europeans, but as nationalists of the soon-to-be-reborn national state of Israel.”
Furthermore, the author also accentuates this same idea by agreeing with Harry Warners writings in Niekas, by stating,
“We squirm and we remember because it is not “them” but “us” who thought those awful thoughts, and hence instigated those awful deeds; and the “us” includes the Jewish nationalistic fanatics, some of whom live today in Israel, who invade schools, break up grammar school class meetings with their queasy-military thugs … because the teacher of the class is not racially “correct.” In this case, however, not sufficiently Jewish, rather than sufficiently German.”
Moreover, Dick clearly shows how Nazism has produced such a hypocritical and conniving movement (Zionism) that has been established on the inhumane tactics and methods, which seem to have been passed down from Nazism itself:
“We like to think of the victims of tyranny and cruelty as innocent (e.g., Chessman). But often the victim is bloodstained, too; i.e., he has participated actively in the situation that has at last claimed his life. Many Jews today wont ride in a VW, and some wont even listen to the music of Beethoven is this not as neurotic and “sick” as was the nineteenth-century ideologies of blood, race, and land being taught by both Germans and Jewish-Germans?
Finally, the author wraps up his essay about the ideological justification of Nazism atrocities committed against the Jews, by comparing it to the justification of the Jewish nationalists (Zionists) atrocities that are currently being committed against the Palestinian people. Dick concludes by stating, “Israel exists, and Jews exist. And –let us face it: Germany exists. Let’s live in the present and for the future, not dwelling neurotically on the outrages of the past.”
This would be convenient to claim when you’re the winning entity in any conflict, like the Jewish nationalists who suffered from WWII. However, the real question that Dick should be asking is ‘why should the Palestinian people suffer ongoing violent injustice, displacement, genocide, and persecution, for 60 years, and for something that Germany is the cause for? Wouldn’t it be more logical and sane to hold the responsible party accountable for its own actions? Shouldn’t the German government suffer consequences for its actions, or atleast play a larger role in the peace process? What people forget to mention and realize is the other information available out there regarding this matter.
For example, Jewish nationalists that used the calamity of WWII to their advantage in establishing their own Jewish state were successful in their tactics of manipulation and blatant duplicity, with the full-fledged support of the western super powers, regarding their cause. This could not have happened without the help of the founding father of Zionism, and also served as the driving forced behind the establishment of the Jewish state of Israel, Theodor Herzl.
When you have a state that was established on theories of people like the founder of Zionism, you can find that this is a clear indication of the injustice committed on the Palestinian people. For example, Herzl writes in his diary “The Jewish State,” about the use of anti-Semitism, and how it has served the Jewish causes interests by serving its own agenda by establishing Israel. Herzl stated in his diary in the late 1800's:
“It is essential that the sufferings of Jews.. . become worse. . . this will assist in realization of our plans. . .I have an excellent idea. . . I shall induce anti-Semites to liquidate Jewish wealth. . . The anti-Semites will assist us thereby in that they will strengthen the persecution and oppression of Jews. The anti-Semites shall be our best friends”.
The current turmoil in the Middle East region, along with the resentment of the Palestinians towards Israelis; because of the blatant inhumane injustice they have received for the past 60 years, will only inflame the friction throughout the whole region. I think of it this way, if the Palestinians and many Arab nations have lost too much already, they don’t have anything else to lose. This can be of grave danger for Israel if it forgets to realize that it’s completely bordered with countries who will seek revenge. This constant living in fear has made this Jewish state live in a sense of hysteria and heightened level of security at all times, and never lived in peace.
References:
- Dick, P.K. (1995). Nazism and the High Castle. In Sutin, L.(Ed.), The Shifting Realities of Philip K. Dick (pp. 112-117). New york: Vintage.
- Theodor Herzl, the Founder of Zionism. (n.d.). True Torah Jews Against Zionism. Retrieved September 05, 2011, from http://www.jewsagainstzionism.com/zionism/herzl/index.cfm
Wednesday, September 7, 2011
Week 7: What does Dick (1995) himself theorise about the I Ching?
In Schizophrenia & The book of Changes, the author Phillip K. Dick describes his personal thoughts and experiences about a thought process that not many people will ever have a good idea about, unless if your diagnosed or suffering from the illness itself. So reading about his personal experiences and thoughts can only give us readers a small idea of how this formation and complex set of structure functions with the use of I Ching.
Dick first starts off by mentioning his ideas about how many life forms are forced into existence, more specifically the koinos kosmos (the shared world), and that the idios kosmos (the personal world) for animals ceases for them as soon as they are born; but not for humans. He emphasizes on how a human child is born into
“…a form of semi real existence ahead of him: semireal in the sense that until he is didteen or sixteen years old he is able to some degree to remain not throroughly born, unknot entirely on his own; fragments of the idios kosmos remain, and not all or even very much of the koinos kosmos has been forced onto him as yet. The full burden of the noisnos kosmos does not weigh until what is delightfully referred to as “psychosecual maturity” sticks, which means those lovely days during high school epitomized by asking that cute girl in the new ahead of you if she’d like to go get a soda after school,” followed by a rejection.
Moreover, Dick shifts his thoughts from personal experiences to explain a personality type that has a state characterized by the coexistence of contradictory or incompatible elements, “Schizophrenia.” He mentions that the personality, which is in his own opinion, “is generally called ‘schizoid effective,’” and gives us an example of his own schizoid effective actions during his adolescence.
With this in mind, the author displays what distinguishes a Schizophrenic from the rest of “us.” Which is the ability not to feel time pass by, where as the rest of “us” experience it and feel it slowly pass by. The author forgets to mentions what and who he means by “us.” Does he mean regular non-Schizophrenic people, or people like himself, Schizophrenics?
Consequently, the author connects the powers from using the I Ching. He first gives a description of how this book, also known as the ‘Book of Changes,’ was first written by a Chinese King who was imprisoned for the rest of his life, and later became Schizophrenic because of his long incarceration. He wrote this book on the “basis of synchronicity- and is a device by which synchronicity can be handled.” Or, as the author mentioned, “you prefer the word ‘coincidence.’ Any how, both terms refer to acausal connectives, or rather events linked in that manner, events occurring outside of time.”
Additionally, the author tells the reader that the universe of the Schizophrenic is somewhat large. “Much too large. Ours, is controlled and finite; we rub up against only as much reality as we an handle—or think we can handle, to be more accurate.” With this in mind, it is evident that the sporadic stream of consciousness that the author displays throughout his writing only proves to show the seriousness of his illness.
Consequently, Dick connects these complex and opposing ideas with the ability to predict the future. He believes that the I Ching, for Schizophrenics, can be a tool or guide for living their daily lives. Since their whole psychological thought process is based on speculation and fear, they can use the I Ching to help make clear which answer to choose, and in some odd cases depending on how serious the illness is, it can tell you the future.
To sum up, Author Dick shares from his own ideas and experiences of what he believes the powers of the I Ching may possess, and that it will only show this power to those who are able to see it through this illness, Schizophrenia. But he emphasizes his negation of this idea much further by saying,
“Sure, we can tinker around and fix matters up so that it does depict the future precisely. But that would be to become Schizophrenic, or anyhow more Schizophrenic. It would be greater loss than gain; we would have induced our future into being consumed by the present. To understand the future totally would be to have it now.”
He concludes by suggesting that if you’re a person that suffers from Schizophrenia, then “by all means use the I Ching for everything, including telling you when to take a bath and when to open a can of cat tuna for your cat Rover.” But if your not a Schizophrenic, then you should basically take the I Ching with a grain of salt.
Reference:
- Sutin, L. (Ed.). (1995) The Shifting Realities of Philip K. Dick (pp.175-182). New york: Vintage.
